Yong Wang · Xiongsheng Liu · Fengfan Chen ·Ronglin Huang · Xiaojun Deng · Yi Jiang

Abstract Soil microbial biomass is an important indicator to measure the dynamic changes of soil carbon pool. It is of great signif icance to understand the dynamics of soil microbial biomass in plantation for rational management and cultivation of plantation. In order to explore the temporal dynamics and inf luencing factors of soil microbial biomass of Keteleeria fortunei var. cyclolepis at different stand ages, the plantation of different ages (young forest, 5 years;middle-aged forest, 22 years; mature forest, 40 years) at the Guangxi Daguishan forest station of China were studied to examine the seasonal variation of their microbial biomass carbon (MBC) and microbial biomass nitrogen (MBN) by chloroform fumigation extraction method. It was found that among the forests of different age, MBC and MBN differed signif icantly in the 0—10 cm soil layer, and MBN differed signif icantly in the 10—20 cm soil layer, but there was no signif icant difference in MBC for the 10—20 cm soil layer or in either MBC or MBN for the 20—40 cm soil layer. With increasing maturity of the forest, MBC gradually decreased in the 0—10 cm soil layer and increased f irstly and then decreased in the 10—20 cm and 20—40 cm soil layers, and MBN increased f irstly and then decreased in all three soil layers. As the soil depth increased, both MBC and MBN gradually decreased for all three forests. The MBC and MBN basically had the same seasonal variation in all three soil layers of all three forests, i.e., high in the summer and low in the winter. Correlation analysis showed that MBC was signif icantly positively correlated with soil organic matter, total nitrogen, and soil moisture, whereas MBN was signif icantly positively correlated with soil total nitrogen. It showed that soil moisture content was the main factor determining the variation of soil microbial biomass by Redundancy analysis.The results showed that the soil properties changed continuously as the young forest grew into the middle-aged forest,which increased soil microbial biomass and enriched the soil nutrients. However, the soil microbial biomass declined as the middle-age forest continued to grow, and the soil nutrients were reduced in the mature forest.

Keywords Microbial bioma ss · Soil mic robial nitr ogen ·Soil mic robial c arbon · Seasonal v ariation · Artif icial forest · Keteleeria fortunei var. cyclolepis

Introduction

The soil microbial biomass regulates the carbon and nitrogen cycle in terrestrial ecosystems and also plays a key role in the conversion and supply of nutrients (Berg and Smalla 2009). To ensure effective management and cultivation of plantation, it is imperative to thoroughly understand the dynamic changes of soil microbial biomass and its influencing factors during forest growth. The soil microbial biomass usually exhibits seasonal variation because it is strongly affected by water, temperature, soil physicochemical properties, nutrients, etc., all of which are in turn highly seasonal (Yao et al. 2011; Wang et al.2016). Previous studies on the seasonal variation of soil microbial biomass in plantation mainly focused on the differences in land use pattern (Pandey et al. 2010; Li et al. 2018), forest type (Ravindran and Yang 2015), and forest age (Wen et al. 2014). For plantation of different age, existing studies on the soil microbial biomass have studied the surface soil layer (＜ 20 cm) of broad-leaved forests in tropical, subtropical, and temperate areas as well as of coniferous forests in subpolar areas (Yang et al.2010; Vidyanagar 2010), but research is lacking on the soil microbial biomass of coniferous forests in subtropical regions or of deep soil layers.

In China, Guangxi is a major area for the production of high-valued tropical and subtropical tree species.Although the local geographical conditions are particularly suitable for the cultivation of high-valued tree species, the development of high-valued tree species is presently lacking. The three fast-growing tree species(Pinaceae, Cunninghamia,Eucalyptus) are the dominant species, but the potential of forest lands remains to be further exploited since other trees are largely neglected.For the sake of local economy in the mountainous areas of Guangxi, it is very important to make full use of the ecological advantages of Guangxi (in both tree species resources and geographical environment) and actively develop plantation of high-valued tree species to improve the productivity of forest land.Keteleeria fortuneivar.cyclolepisis a high-valued native tree species in Guangxi that belongs to theKeteleeriagenus of the Pinaceae family. It has very high economic value because it is an excellent species for both landscaping and the production of precious timber, and it is also an ideal species for reforestation in mountains (Liu et al. 2017). Present research on the artificial forest ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisfocused mostly on the effects of topography, meteorology, and habitat on the forest growth and biomass, as well as the physiochemical properties of the forest soil (Huang et al.2016), and there is currently no published work on the soil microbial biomass.

In this paper, seasonal dynamics of soil microbial biomass inK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantation forests of different age at the Guangxi Daguishan forest station was studied to understand whether the changes of soil microbial biomass during the growth ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantation changed its soil properties. The soil fertility status was analyzed, and the relevant factors affecting the soil microbial biomass were discussed. The results provide a scientif ic basis for the rational management ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantation as well as cultivation of other coniferous forests in tropical and subtropical regions.

Materials a nd methods

Study s ite

The test sites (111° 20′ 5′ E, 24° 14′ 25′ N) are located at the Liupai branch of the Daguishan forest station in the northeast to the Hezhou city of Guangxi, China. The landform consists of low hills and low mountains, and the elevation is 80—1204 m. The test sites have humid subtropical monsoon climate with an average annual temperature of 19.3 °C, an average annual rainfall of 2056 mm, and an average relative humidity of 82% (Liu et al. 2017). The soil is developed from residual parent material and consists mainly of mountainous brow soil. The soil texture is clay.The soil thickness is about 90—120 cm. The selected test sites have essentially uniform environmental conditions and management measures. The age of the artif icialK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisforests varies from 5 years (young forest) to 22 years (middle-aged forest) and 40 years (mature forest).Additional information of the test sites is given in Table 1.

Methods

Three replicate plots (20 m × 20 m) were randomly selected in each forest site, and soil samples were taken at the nine plots from soil layers at 0—10, 10—20, and 20—40 cm in March, June, September, and December of 2016, hence each time 27 samples were brought back to the laboratory for analysis. Each fresh soil sample was divided into two parts. The f irst half was passed through a stainless steel f ilter(2 mm) and measured for soil microbial carbon (MBC) and soil microbial nitrogen (MBN), and the other half was airdried, sifted, and measured for soil organic carbon (SOC),total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), pH, bulk density(BD), and soil water content (SWC) (Oksanen 2001; Binkley and Fisher 2012).The MBC and MBN were measured by chloroform fumigation (Vance et al. 1987). Soil was weighed(10.00 g × 4) to give four portions, which were placed in a vacuum dryer containing chloroform and incubated at 25 °C for 24 h. The soil samples before and after fumigation were mixed with aqueous K2SO4(0.5 mol/L, 40 mL), shaken at 300 rpm for 30 min, and sifted. The f iltrate was measured on a multi N/C 3100 (Analytik Jena AG, Germany) instrument.

Soil organic carbon was determined by combustion method and multi N/C 2100 analyzer (Analytik Jena AG,Jena German). Soil total nitrogen was determined by Kjeldahl method using Automatic kjeldahl apparatus (Kjeltec 8400, Foss, Hiller d, Danmark). The content of phosphorus was determined by molybdenum-antimony colorimeter using uv-2600 spectrophotometer. The soil pH was determined by the glass electrode method. The soil bulk density was calculated by dividing the dry soil weight by the volume of the ring knife used for sampling (Binkley and Fisher 2012).

,octophylla rubra us alatus, Psychotria irta s, Schefflera, Ficus h ia lepta orifoliu onym bus corch irta, Rubus corchorifolius, Eu ra chinensis, Ru tiumbarometz, Evod positions s cochinchinensis ra , Cibo Phylla Shrub com p y d e n s i t y Schisandnthu Ficus h Psychotria rub Cano 0.2 0.5 0.7 850 435 e n-s i t y (N/h m 2 )H (c m)S it e d 1600 3.5 h ei gh t (m)M ea n.3.5 20 31 DB f K. fortunei var. cyclolepis at diff erent sites 1.7.6.5 ree Mean 18 22 e deg elow e b 25°25°ect Slope position Slop 15°he sam e slop e e slop Down Down slop Down mature forest. T Basic situation of the plantation o e asp rest, MF fo Southeast Southeast Age (a) Altitude (m) Slop Southeast iddle-aged 5 46 67 F m 45 43 5 Table 1 F 22 40 ung forest, MA Site YF MA MF yo YF

Data anal ysis

The seasonal variation of the soil physicochemical properties and microbial biomass of the artif icialK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisforests of different age was analyzed and plotted with Excel 2007. Variance analysis, Pearson correlation analysis, and Duncan’s multiple range test were conducted with SPSS19.0. The signif icance level for all statistical analyses was set at α = 0.05. In order to ref lect the effect of soil physical and chemical properties on soil microbial biomass, the data of soil microbial biomass and soil physical and chemical properties were sequenced and made redundancy analysis (RDA) by Canoco 5.0 software.

Results

Vertical variation of soil microbial biomass and physicochemical properties

Figure 1 shows the vertical variation of the soil physicochemical properties and the microbial biomass. For the 0—10 cm soil layer, signif icant difference among forests of different age was found (P＜ 0.05) for TN, TP, MBC,and MBN, but not (P＞ 0.05) for SOC, pH, BD, SWC, and MBC/MBN. For the 10—20 cm soil layer, signif icant difference among forests of different age was found for SOC,TN, MBC, and MBC/MBN, but did not exist for MBN, TP,pH, BD, and SWC. For the 20—40 cm soil layer, there was no signif icant difference among forests of different age for MBC, MBN, MBC/MBN, SOC, TN, TP, pH, BD, and SWC.In general, for the soil of all three forest sites, SOC, TN,TP, SWC, MBC, MBN gradually decreased with soil depth,BD increased with soil depth, and pH and MBC/MBN did not seem to clearly vary with soil depth. For the young forest, there was extremely signif icant difference among soil layers for SOC, TN, and TP but no signif icant difference for pH, BD, and SWC. For the middle-aged forest, there was extremely signif icant difference among soil layers for SOC, TN, and TP, signif icant difference for SWC, and no signif icant difference for pH and BD. For the mature forest,there was extremely signif icant difference among soil layers for SOC, TN, and TP, but no signif icant difference for pH,BD, and SWC.

Seasonal v ariation of s oil mic robial biomas s

Fig. 1 The vertical changes in soil microbial biomass and physicochemical properties at different sites of artif icial K. fortunei var.cyclolepis forests. Different capital letters of the same site indicate signif icant differences between soil layers, and different lower case letters of the same soil layer indicate signif icant differences across forest sites

Figure 2 shows the seasonal variation of the soil microbial biomass for the artif icialK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisforests of different age. It can be noted that for all soil layers of all forest sites, both MBC and MBN were the highest in summer and the lowest in winter. For the 0—10 cm soil, MBC and MBN fell in the order of summer ＞ fall ＞ spring ＞ winter. For the 20—40 cm soil, MBC and MBN fell in the order of summer ＞ spring ＞ fall ＞ winter. For the 10—20 cm soil,except the MBC of the young forest showed an order of summer ＞ spring ＞ fall ＞ winter, the MBC of the middle-aged and mature forests, as well as the MBN of all three forest,all showed the order of summer ＞ fall ＞ spring ＞ winter.

The seasonal variation of MBC/MBN was different.For the 0—10 cm soil, the MBC/MBN of all three forests fell in the order of spring ＞ summer ＞ winter ＞ fall. For the 10—20 cm soil, the MBC/MBN of the young forest fell in the order of spring ＞ winter ＞ fall ＞ summer, and the MBC/MBN of the middle-aged and mature forests fell in the order of spring ＞ fall ＞ winter ＞ summer. For the 20—40 cm soil, the MBC/MBN of young and middle-aged forests fell in the order of spring ＞ summer ＞ winter ＞ fall, and the MBC/MBN of the mature forest fell in the order of winter ＞ spring ＞ fall ＞ summer.

Inf luence factors for the soil microbial biomass

Pearson correlation analysis (Table 2) showed that for the 0—10 cm soil, signif icant positive correlation existed between MBC and SOC, TN, SWC as well as between MBC/MBNand SOC, and there was also extremely signif icant positive correlation between MBN and TN. For the 10—20 cm soil,there were extremely signif icant positive correlation between MBC and SOC, signif icant positive correlation between MBN and TN, significant positive correlation between MBC/MBN and SOC, and signif icant negative correlation between MBC/MBN and TN. For the 20—40 cm soil, signif icant positive correlation existed between MBN and TN.

Fig. 2 The seasonal variation in soil microbial biomass at different forest sites of K. fortunei var. cyclolepis (Mean ± SE)

Table 2 Correlation between soil microbial biomass and inf luence factors

According to the RDA ordination diagram (Fig. 3), the total explanatory rate of soil physicochemical properties to microbial biomass change is 97.3%, the explanatory rates of axis I and axis II are 91.42% and 5.69%, respectively, and the cumulative explanatory rate is 97.11%, accounting for 98.8%of the total explanatory rate. It showed that the f irst two axes could ref lect the relationship between soil microbial biomass and physicochemical properties well. After gradual selection of SWC, SOC, TN, pH, BD and TP, the cumulative values of explanatory variables were 75.6%, 94.2%, 95.3%, 96.5%,97.2% and 97.3%, indicating that SWC was the main factor determining the variation of soil microbial biomass, and its explanatory rate was 75.6%.

Discussions

Difference in the soil microbial biomass of different forests

Fig. 3 RDA ordination diagram of soil microbial biomass and physicochemical properties

The results showed that there was signif icant differences in soil microbial biomass between different forest ages in the 0—20 cm soil layer. With the increase of soil depth, there were no signif icant differences in soil microbial biomass between different forest ages, and both MBC and MBN gradually decreased. It indicated that the microbial biomass was more enriched and had greater diversity in the surface soil layers (0—10 and 10—20 cm) than in the deep soil layer (20—40 cm) for theK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantations of different ages. It can be seen that the forest age strongly affected the soil microbial biomass in the surface layers. It is consistent with the research results of Xu et al. ( 2013) and Wen et al. ( 2014). However, the study of An et al. ( 2011) showed that the number of microorganisms was the highest in the soil layer of 10—40 cm, which maybe because the soil in the study area was sandy loam,and water and nutrients were easily diffused and leached to the deep layer, leading to the enrichment of microorganisms in the deep layer. The study area belongs to dark brown forest soil with more inputs of f ine roots and litters and better ventilation and permeability in the surface soil,which was conducive to the growth and reproduction of microorganisms. On the other hand, as the soil layer deepened, soil water content decreased and the soil porosity declined which reduced the ion exchange in soil, impeded the diffusion of nutrients, and impaired the growth and distribution of soil microbes. There were no signif icant differences in the nutrients and physicochemical properties of soil among forests of different age, and thus their soil microbial biomass could not be well distinguished from each other (Fierer et al. 2003; Stockdale and Brookes 2006).

Generally speaking, as the age of the forest increased, the soil microbial biomass increased f irstly and then decreased,in the order of middle-aged forest ＞ young forest ＞ mature forest. This was in line with the results reported by Wu et al.( 2016) on the soil microbes of theLarix principis-rupprechtiiMayr forests at the Shanxi Taiyue mountain. It could be speculated that the young forest ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepishad smaller trees, and forest f loor light, humidity, and temperature were all favorable to the metabolism and growth of soil microbes. As the forest age increased, the amount of litter increased, which enriched the soil nutrients and provided additional energy source for microbial metabolism and synthesis. However, when the forest matured further, the canopy of the forests became denser, which reduced forest f loor light and slowed decomposition of litter. Vegetations such as shrubs and herbs also declined consequently, which decreased soil nutrients and together lead to slower microbial growth (Kaiser et al. 2011; Song et al. 2015).

The ratio of soil microbial carbon to soil microbial nitrogen is often used as an important indicator of changes in the microbial community, and higher ratio indicates higher fungal biomass (Zhou and Wang 2015). In this study, there was no signif icant difference in MBC/MBN in soil layers of 0—10 cm and 20—40 cm between different forest ages, while MBC/MBN in soil layers of 10—20 cm was signif icantly different between different forest ages, and MBC/MBN in soil of young and medium forests was signif icantly greater than that in forest (Fig. 2). It indicated thatK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantations had little effect on the microbial community in the soil surface (0—10 cm) and deep (20—40 cm),but greater effect on the microbial community in the soil middle (10—20 cm). It may be that the soil organic matter was benef icial to the growth of soil fungal growth, while total nitrogen content was benef icial to the growth of the soil bacteria. There was signif icant differences between soil organic matter and total nitrogen content in 10—20 cm soil layer of different forest ages, which causes the difference of MBC/MBN in the soil layer of different forest ages. The specif ic i mechanism and reason of the impact still needed further in-depth study (Trap et al. 2011). With the deepening of soil layer, the MBC/MBN ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantation increased gradually, which similar to the previous research results (Fierer et al. 2003; An et al. 2011). It mainly because the soil surface nutrient limit was lower and it was more suitable for bacteria to survive.

Seasonal v ariation and inf luence factors of soil microbial biomass

The seasonal soil microbial biomass is strongly affected by humidity, temperature, soil physicochemical properties, and other environmental factors (Classen et al. 2007; Freppaz et al. 2014). In the current study of the artif icialK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisforests, the observed soil microbial carbon(MBC) and soil microbial nitrogen (MBN) were clearly high in the summer and low in the winter. That is, MBC and MBN were high in the growth season and low in the hibernation season. Similar trend was also observed by Devi and Yadava ( 2006) for the mixed forest ofQuercus Linnin Manipur, India, by Ruan et al. ( 2004) for tropical rainforest,as well as by Li et al. ( 2014) for the mixed forest ofCunninghamia lanceolataHook,Pinus massonianaLamb andLithocarpus glaberNakai in the hilly areas of central Hunan in China. The higher temperature in the summer promotes the decomposition of litter, and nutrients and carbohydrates are brought into the soil from the earth surface by rain water,which accelerates the growth of soil microbes and increases both MBC and MBN. Conversely, since the winter is colder and drier, the decomposition of litter is slower and both microbial growth and activity are inhibited, leading to lower MBC and MBN (Lipson and Schmidt 2000). The seasonal variation of soil MBC/MBN inK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantations of different forest ages also showed a certain rule, which was mainly manifested as that the soil MBC/MBN of the three forest ages was the largest in spring, and the soil MBC/MBN of the young and middle forests was greater than that of the mature forests, especially in the soil layer of 10—40 cm. We speculated that this may be caused by the increase of external temperature in spring, the smaller canopy density in young and middle forests, and the more sensitive response of surface soil to external temperature and the more light it received, which is conducive to fungus breeding and growth (Kaiser et al. 2014; Jefferies et al.2010).

Soil microbial biomass is related to environmental factors such as temperature, humidity, soil moisture, soil nutrients,soil physicochemical properties, etc. (Devi and Yadava 2006;Liu et al. 2014). Current results showed that in the plantation ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepis, MBC was signif icantly positively correlated with soil organic matter, total nitrogen,and soil moisture, while MBN was signif icantly positively correlated with soil total nitrogen. Therefore, soil organic matter and total nitrogen were important inf luence factors of MBC and MBN. High soil organic matter and total nitrogen can provide the soil microbes with sufficient carbon, nitrogen, and energy source for their synthesis and metabolism(Li et al. 2014). These results are consistent with previous f indings. Yang et al. ( 2009) studied the seasonal changes of soil microbial biomass in the plantation ofLarix gmeliniiKuzen and found signif icantly positive correlation between soil microbial biomass (both carbon and nitrogen) and soil organic matter and total nitrogen. The global analysis by Xu et al. ( 2013) on the soil microbial biomass (carbon, nitrogen,and phosphorus) in terrestrial ecosystems demonstrated that the spatial pattern of soil microbial biomass (carbon and nitrogen) was consistent with that of soil organic matter and total nitrogen.

In conclusion, the soil nutrients in middle age were more nutritious than young and mature forests ofK. fortuneivar.cyclolepisplantations, that is to say, the soil nutrients gradually increased with the development of the plantations,and reached the maximum at middle age. And then the soil nutrients gradually decreased with the increase of forest age,while the soil fertility declines also.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ( http://creat iveco mmons.org/licen ses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.